Reading Time: 7 minutes

Vegan vs Fruitarian Diet – Introduction

Are you looking for a diet to help you lead a healthy and sustainable lifestyle? If yes, then it’s very likely that you’ve come across two popular diets: vegan and fruitarian. While both diets promote the consumption of plant-based foods, they differ in their food restrictions.

Briefly Define Vegan and Fruitarian Diets

A vegan diet is a plant-based diet that excludes all animal products, including meat, dairy, eggs, honey, and sometimes even processed foods made with animal-derived ingredients. Vegans rely on grains, legumes, nuts, seeds, fruits, and vegetables for their nutrition.

A fruitarian diet takes the concept of veganism to another level by restricting themselves to only fruits (including nuts and seeds) that have fallen off their trees or plants naturally. They do not consume any vegetables or grains.

State the Main Argument: Is a Vegan Diet More Restrictive than a Fruitarian Diet?

Vegan vs Fruitarian Diet

One of the most common arguments when it comes to comparing these two diets is which one is more restrictive. While vegans cannot consume anything derived from an animal source (even if it’s hidden), fruitarians restrict themselves to only consuming fruits that have naturally fallen off their tree or plant.

But does this mean one is more restrictive than the other? Let’s find out!

What is a Vegan Diet?

A vegan diet is a type of vegetarian diet that excludes all animal products, including meat, dairy, eggs, and even honey. This means that people who follow a vegan diet consume only plant-based foods such as fruits, vegetables, grains, legumes, nuts, and seeds.

Definition of a Vegan Diet

The term “vegan” was coined in 1944 by Donald Watson, who believed that the word vegetarian did not adequately describe those who abstained from eating animal products altogether. A vegan diet is not just about what you eat; it’s also about avoiding animal-derived clothing materials such as leather and wool.

Foods allowed and restricted in a vegan diet

Vegans have plenty of options when it comes to food because there are many plant-based alternatives available. Foods that are allowed on a vegan diet include fruits, vegetables, whole grains, beans and legumes like chickpeas or lentils. Restrictive foods include anything derived from animals, such as meat, and dairy products like milk, cheese, and eggs.

Health benefits of a vegan diet

Studies have shown that following a vegan diet can lead to several health benefits, such as a lower risk for heart disease and certain types of cancer. Vegans also tend to have lower body mass index (BMI) values than non-vegans which can lead to better overall health.

Additionally, consuming more fruits and vegetables instead of processed foods containing preservatives or additives avoids potential health issues associated with those additives. , a vegan diet involves consuming only plant-based foods while excluding all animal products, including meat, dairy, eggs, and honey. It offers numerous health benefits, including a lower risk for heart disease, certain types of cancer, and low BMI values. Veganism is not just about what you eat; it’s also about avoiding animal-derived clothing materials such as leather and wool.

What is a Fruitarian Diet?

Fruitarians are a subgroup of vegans who rely solely on fruits, nuts, seeds, and other plant-based foods that can be harvested without killing the plant. The fruitarian diet follows the principle of “ethical fruitarianism,” which involves consuming only foods that have naturally fallen from the plant or tree to avoid causing harm to live beings.

Vegan vs Fruitarian Diet

Food allowed and restricted in a Fruitarian Diet.

A fruitarian diet primarily consists of fresh fruits, including those that are sweet and non-sweet, such as apples, bananas, berries, citrus fruits, melons, dates, and figs. It also includes some vegetables such as cucumber and tomatoes but restricts all other food groups like grains or legumes. Nuts and seeds may be included occasionally, but only if they haven’t been roasted or processed.

The Health Benefits of a Fruitarian Diet

When done correctly with careful consideration given to the nutritional value and variety in one’s intake of fruit options, a fruitarian diet is high in fiber while low in fat, which can help manage weight levels. Additionally, it supports healthy digestion thanks to its high water content.

Its reliance on raw foods means that it allows for maximum nutrient intake since cooking can often destroy essential vitamins. However, it is important to note that while there are clear benefits to this lifestyle choice, there are also notable drawbacks, including protein deficiency which can affect muscle mass development as well as being deficient in essential vitamins like B-12, which cannot be sourced from plants alone

Comparison between Vegan and Fruitarian Diets

Both vegan and fruitarian diets have their own unique set of food restrictions that set them apart from other diets. While a vegan diet excludes all animal products, including meat, dairy, eggs, and even honey, a fruitarian diet goes even further by excluding all plant-based foods except for fruits and occasionally nuts or seeds.

Differences in Food Restrictions

The primary difference between these two diets is the extent of their food restrictions. Vegans can still enjoy a varied diet with plenty of protein sources from beans, lentils, tofu, tempeh, and seitan. They can also get essential nutrients like calcium from fortified plant-based milk or leafy greens.

Fruitarians may struggle to meet their basic nutritional needs due to the lack of variety in their diet. They may risk deficiencies in essential nutrients like vitamin B12, iron, zinc, calcium, and omega-3 fatty acids found in animal-based products or fortified foods.

Nutritional Adequacy of Both Diets

While both vegan and fruitarian diets can be nutritionally balanced if done correctly with proper planning and supplement use (for B12 deficiency), individual variations can bring differences in nutritional adequacy for each individual.

Vegan vs Fruitarian Diet

Protein Intake

A common concern regarding veganism is protein intake, but with careful planning, it’s possible to get enough through plant-based proteins such as soy products. On the other hand, Fruitarians might struggle with obtaining enough protein as fruits have minimal amounts.

Vitamin and Mineral Deficiencies

Veganism already has some risks regarding certain vitamin deficiencies like B12, which are primarily available through animal sources, but through supplements or fortified foods, it’s possible to obtain enough. Fruitarians, however, might have more issues with zinc, vitamin D, and calcium deficiencies as most of these come from non-fruit items.


Both veganism and fruitarianism can be sustainable diets if followed correctly. However, given the lack of variety in a fruitarian diet, it may not be as sustainable in the long term. For example, fruits are expensive and seasonal, which might lead to difficulty maintaining a consistent diet throughout the year.

Overall, while both diets have their pros and cons, vegans have an easier time meeting their nutritional needs while still enjoying a varied diet. A fruitarian diet may not provide enough nutrients for everyone, especially when it comes to prioritizing certain nutrients over others, making it more restrictive than a vegan one.

The Restrictiveness Factor

Factors that determine the restrictiveness of each diet

When it comes to determining how restrictive a diet is, there are several key factors to consider. These include the availability of food options, social situations, and personal preferences. Additionally, it’s important to note that what one person finds restrictive may not be the same as another.

Availability of food options

One factor that can make a vegan or fruitarian diet more or less restrictive is the availability of food options. For example, if you live in an area with limited access to fresh fruits and vegetables, a fruitarian diet may be more difficult to follow than a vegan one. However, a vegan diet may feel more restrictive if you have access to plenty of plant-based options but struggle with finding enough variety within those foods.

Social situations (eating out, family gatherings)

Another factor that can impact how restrictive a particular diet feels is the social situation. If you frequently eat out with friends or family members who are not plant-based eaters, then both diets may feel equally challenging in terms of finding suitable meal options. However, if you have a strong support network that understands and respects your dietary choices, then this can help alleviate feelings of restriction.

Personal preferences

Ultimately, personal preferences are major in how restrictive any given diet feels. Some people thrive on the simplicity and purity of a fruitarian diet and find joy in only eating raw fruits and vegetables. Others may prefer the wider range of options on a vegan diet but still limit their intake of processed foods or animal products for health or ethical reasons.

Whether or not one chooses to follow a vegan or fruitarian diet ultimately comes down to individual preference and lifestyle factors such as available resources and social support networks. While some may find one diet more restrictive than the other, it’s important to remember that both can be healthy and sustainable options when approached mindfully and with intention.


Recap on the main argument: Is one more restrictive than the other?

After comparing and contrasting the vegan and fruitarian diets, it is clear that both have their own unique set of challenges and restrictions. While a vegan diet restricts animal-based products, a fruitarian diet is even more restrictive by only allowing fruits, nuts, and seeds. However, both diets can be nutritionally adequate with careful planning and attention to nutrient intake.

Final thoughts on which one may be more suitable for certain individuals

It’s important to consider personal preferences and lifestyles when choosing between a vegan or fruitarian diet. Those who prefer a wider variety of food options may find a vegan diet more suitable for them.

However, individuals who are passionate about eating only whole, raw fruits may find that a fruitarian diet aligns better with their values. Ultimately, it is up to each individual to decide what works best for their health and lifestyle.

It’s important to consult with a healthcare professional or registered dietitian before making any significant dietary changes. With careful planning and consideration, vegan and fruitarian diets can be healthy for those seeking plant-based lifestyles.


Are Funnel Cakes Vegan? Tempting Delight or Vegan's Plight?


Finding Relief: How a Vegan Diet Can Soothe Your IBS Symptoms

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Check Also

Fiverr is an online marketplace that connects freelancers with clients seeking various services. It offers a wide range of digital services, including graphic design, writing, programming, marketing, and in my case, a nutritionist! Freelancers create gigs, specifying what they can offer and at what price, and clients browse these gigs to find the services they need. Fiverr's platform provides a convenient and accessible way for individuals and businesses to outsource tasks and find skilled professionals for their projects.